50 Best New York Used Subaru Legacy for Sale, Savings from $3,479

2013 Subaru Legacy
93,423 Miles | Middle Village, NY
$8,995
est. $130/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2015 Subaru Legacy
143,511 Miles | Brooklyn, NY
$8,995
est. $130/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2011 Subaru Legacy
143,387 Miles | Brooklyn, NY
Accepting Offers
est. $0/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2010 Subaru Legacy
143,774 Miles | Brooklyn, NY
Accepting Offers
est. $0/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
3,097 Miles | Long Island City, NY
$20,889
est. $301/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
37,213 Miles | Long Island City, NY
$21,588
est. $311/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
21,520 Miles | Long Island City, NY
$19,995
est. $288/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
57,848 Miles | Long Island City, NY
$15,995
est. $231/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
32,942 Miles | Long Island City, NY
$19,995
est. $288/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
44,524 Miles | Long Island City, NY
Accepting Offers
est. $0/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
33,401 Miles | Long Island City, NY
$17,995
est. $259/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2014 Subaru Legacy
49,877 Miles | Jackson Heights, NY
$11,448
est. $165/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2016 Subaru Legacy
71,036 Miles | Union City, NJ
$14,990
est. $216/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2012 Subaru Legacy
115,328 Miles | Union City, NJ
Accepting Offers
est. $0/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2006 Subaru Legacy
132,193 Miles | Brooklyn, NY
$5,497
est. $79/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
67,217 Miles | Jersey City, NJ
$13,499
est. $195/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2016 Subaru Legacy
12,688 Miles | Jersey City, NJ
$13,995
est. $202/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
98,523 Miles | Jersey City, NJ
$14,546
est. $210/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2014 Subaru Legacy
130,880 Miles | Brooklyn, NY
$7,399
est. $107/mo

Track Price Check Availability

2017 Subaru Legacy
41,439 Miles | Valley Stream, NY
$16,490
est. $238/mo

Track Price Check Availability

New York, NY Subaru Legacy Buyer's Guide

Owner Reviews
Overall
4.4
Value
4.3
Performance
3.7
Style
3.9
Comfort
4.1
Fuel Economy
3.8
Reliability
4.2
Top Dealers In New York, NY
  1. West Herr Subaru Orchard Park
  2. Van Bortel Ford East Rochester

Subaru Legacy Owner Ratings & Reviews

Write a Review

2009 Subaru Legacy - Reliable and tough Subaru

Angela
New York, New York
Overall
5.0
Value
5.0
Performance
4.0
Style
4.0
Comfort
5.0
Fuel Economy
4.0
Even though my model is a little on the old side, I absolutely love it! It is always dependable and has a lot of room. I am a big traveler and have driven it all over the place. The fact that it is a wagon some people may not like, but for me it was perfect for any trip. My longest trip was across country and my Subaru got me and my main possessions from Washington State to Philadelphia without any problems in four days. When I got to my destination, all it needed was a simple tune up (and oil change of course). I have never had any serious problems with it and will definitely stick to Subaru most likely then next time I am in the market for a new or used car. Because even used, this car is going to be tough and durable!
Pros
Durable Good gas mileage Cheap to fix
Cons
Not the prettiest of cars

2009 Subaru Legacy -

Legacy Owner
Ithaca, New York
Overall
5.0
Value
5.0
Performance
3.0
Style
4.0
Comfort
4.0
Fuel Economy
3.0
Reliability
4.0
This car has 120,000 miles on it and still runs great. I can drive 5 minutes to the store and 5 minutes back home, or take it upstate for 4 hours on the highway. Either, I have no issues with engine performance. The ride feels smooth and the cabin is relatively quiet. The sunroof is a fun feature for a sunny day because it makes my car feel bigger and more open. I live in rural New York and this car has handled all the snow and ice very well. To top it off, the trim of the body looks respectable and cool so that I have no issues driving around colleagues during the work day if needed.
Story
I once powered up a snowy/icy hill to work while some coworkers had to ditch off to the side in less powerful cars.
Pros
The sunroof is my favorite feature because of the openness it adds to the cabin. The car handles excellent in all types of weather, including snow which is a major issue in my region.
Cons
I have had some issues with resetting codes that pop up on the dashboard. This car is a bit older, so it is reasonable to have some minor electrical issues. Although I couldn't just go to a car parts place to get the codes cleared, a Subaru expert was able to clear everything up for me very quickly. The central cup holder for the driver and co-pilot seat it not very stable and required me to purchase a cheap stabilizer at an auto parts store.

July 2020 New York Subaru Legacy Prices & Rankings

Should you drive for a deal?

New York, NY Dealer Ratings & Reviews

Write a Review

2010 Subaru Impreza - West Herr Subaru Orchard Park

Jack
Orchard Park, New York
Overall
5.0
Facility
5.0
Process
4.0
Quality
5.0
Service
5.0
I was very impressed with this dealer. They worked with me not only on price but also financing, they were very helpful from start to finish with accommodating my schedule and my price range. They were also understanding with all of my concerns and my wish to take the car to my mechanic on a test drive to make sure everything checked out. I would rate this dealership as highly as possible.

2014 Subaru Impreza - Van Bortel Ford East Rochester

Wyatt
East Rochester, New York
Overall
5.0
Facility
5.0
Process
5.0
Quality
5.0
Service
5.0
Van Bortel has a different way of selling cars. They have one list price and do not negotiate on it. This is the lowest market value of the car and you can check it right on Kelly blue book. They have a great reputation in Rochester and I always recommend them for this. It didn't feel like I was pressured into buying the car. The salesman Charlie was awesome as well.